To me, hard disk imaging is one of the most important thing to do after I’ve perfectly finished setting up a computer system the way I wanted. It is the best way of restoring the changes back to the way it was and also the best way to clone multiple computers with same hardware. I’ve always been using the good old Symantec Ghost for DOS version to do all that and only recently I’ve been using Macrium Reflect full edition on my new laptop because it was sponsored by Macrium.
drive imaging software comparison
Since Symantec Ghost Corporate Edition DOS version has never failed me, I never wanted to try out other products including the famous Acronis! However, many years has gone by and I believe the technologies that they used must have improved a lot. Will Symantec Ghost still remain as my favorite disk imaging software? Well I wanted to post this 2 weeks ago but was caught with Norton 15 being released and then Paragon Backup & Recovery 10 Suite. Do note that I am only comparing shareware disk imaging software and the free ones are not included in the list. I hope that this comparison will be able to help you decide which disk imaging is worth buying.

Here are the list of disk imaging software that I have tested:

1. Acronis True Image Home 2010 (build 6.029) – Website
2. Active@ Disk Image v3.34 – Website
3. DriveClone Pro v7 – Website
4. Macrium Reflect v4.2 Build 2028 Full Edition – Website
5. Norton Ghost v15 – Website
6. O&O DiskImage Professional v4.1 Build 47 – Website
7. Paragon Drive Backup v9 Professional Build 8681 – Website
8. R-Drive Image v4.6 Build 4601 – Website
9. Windows 7 built-in Disk Imaging
10. StorageCraft ShadowProtect Desktop Edition v3.5 – Website

The testing was done on my desktop computer:

CPU: Intel Pentium D 2.80GHz
Mainboard: MSI 945P Platinum
Memory: 2GB DDR2
Hard Drive 1: 160GB 7200RPM 8MB Cache SATA 3.0Gb/s (Windows 7),
Hard Drive 2: 250GB 7200RPM 8MB Cache SATA 1.5Gb/s (Backup Location)

I wasn’t able to fully test Active@ Disk Image because the recovery disk feature is not available in the trial version. I emailed them to request for a full version to review but never gotten any reply from them.

Ghost 14 didn’t support Windows 7, so I waited for Ghost 15. When Ghost 15 was officially released last week, they said that they currently do not have any free copies available for the press. So I went ahead and paid $69.99 to purchase a full version for testing.

After finished testing Ghost 15, I then found out Paragon has recently replaced their Drive Backup Professional 9 with Backup & Recovery 10 Suite. I’ve requested for a full trial version and they seemed to be quite reluctant to provide me with a version that I can fully test on. I’d very much like to test and include Paragon Backup & Recovery 10 Suite in the review, but unfortunately I do not have the funds to buy the full version. If they ever provide me with a full version, I will surely update this review.

Macrium, O&O and StorageCraft happily provided me with full version for testing without any delays. I managed to “find” the full version of Acronis, DriveClone, Paragon 9 and R-Drive so I didn’t have to contact them and can’t tell if their support is good or not.

All disk imaging software includes mount/unmount image, verify/validate image, scheduler for automatic creation of backup disk images, raw imaging (sector to sector), and support for Windows 7. So I will not include this 5 features to the comparison table below.

Features Comparison (Click to open image at new window)

Disk Imaging Feature Comparison

Features Explanation:
1: Boot Menu = The imaging software adds the program to Windows start-up boot menu allowing you to run the software for backup/restore without booting in Windows or using the Rescue Disk.
Norton LightsOut
2. Constant Backup = Able to automatically create non-stop backup every X minutes
3. Virtual Environment = Risk free environment for testing of new software or visiting websites with potentially dangerous content.
4. Restore to Different Hardware PC = In another words, it’s called Universal Restore. You can restore the backup image onto another computer without having the same hardware.

Disk Imaging and Restoration Speed (Click to open image at new window)

Disk Imaging Speed Comparison

Here are some notes on the tests and rules of disk imaging:
- The disk imaging backup process is tested with default settings.
- Acronis Online Backup is not available for all countries yet. First 25GB cost $4.95 per month or $49.95 per year. Ever 5GB storage increment cost $0.79 per month or $9.49 per year.
- You can create a full image backup on the Windows where you’re logged on.
- You cannot perform full restoration on the Windows you are logged on. Restoration can only be done with Rescue Disk or Boot Menu where Windows on the hard drive is not loaded.
- Macrium has finally added the ability to create image backup using Rescue Disk but only for Windows PE v2.1.200 and above only. It’s a little buggy because the Rescue Disk backup compression doesn’t seems to compress as good as Macrium running in Windows and it also takes more time.

From the test that I’ve done, I can easily see that there is an obvious winner and that is Acronis TrueImage Home 2010! Acronis is able to backup and restore with very fast speed and also packed with a lot of features that cannot be found on other disk imaging software. Most importantly, the price is reasonable and doesn’t cost ridiculously expensive like its competitors. StorageCraft has the best backup and restore speed with a lot of features but it’s the most expensive.

[tags]image, backup, restore, ghost, acronis[/tags]