5 Tools to Test CD or DVD Readability by a Running Surface Scan and File Test

It’s probably a safe bet that most people who use a computer have come across a CD or DVD that refuses to work properly. If it’s a movie or music, it will probably skip and jump around or get completely stuck during playback. When trying to play a game or read data from the disc you might get a simple error in Windows that the disc cannot be read. Although many users still think CD and DVD discs are pretty much indestructible and last forever, they do in fact degrade over time and have a limited lifespan.

You can also get similar problems if you are burning discs yourself and the media is of poor quality or the data is being burned too quickly for the media to handle. It’s also common for things like fingerprints or scratches to stop disc contents being read properly, maybe even the ROM drive you’re using is the problem and you don’t know. Just like your hard drive in your computer needs to be checked from time to time for errors, it’s useful to be able to scan a CD or DVD to verify the disc is in good condition and all of the data contained on it is completely readable. Here’s a selection of 5 different tools that can help you check the readability of your media. All tools were tested on Windows 7 64-bit and will also work on XP/Vista/8. 1. VSO Inspector

test cd and dvd readability with vso inspector

VSO Inspector is a free utility from the makers of Blindwrite to report information about your computer’s hardware configuration where reading and writing CD’s and DVD’s are concerned. The Device Features tab will give various bits of information about the reading and writing capabilities of your burner along with region code and firmware details, while the Media tab will show information about any inserted media. The sector viewer allows disc sectors to be viewed and saved, the System tab displays any installed filter drivers.

For the purpose of this article, the Scan tab is the most important because it allows you to run a complete scan of an inserted disc and flag any issues with its content. It does so using two different selectable methods; Surface Scan will check the quality of the media surface itself while ignoring the files, File Test checks the files themselves so you can see which ones are a problem if the disc isn’t perfect. An interesting option in Advanced is scan direction, VSO state that to get a quick idea of quality it’s better to check the outer edges of the burn zone first as that’s usually the weakest area.

Download VSO Inspector


2. CDReader 3.0

CDReader file check

CDReader is quite an old tool but it’s quick and simple to use if you just want to verify the contents of your media can be read off the disc. It does this by using the method of simply reading all the files on the CD/DVD like through Explorer as if you were trying to copy them onto your hard drive. Individual files or folders can also be selected in case you’re not worried about checking the complete disc and want to make sure just the important files on it are readable. Hard drive contents can also be scanned if you feel there is a specific need to do so. Select the drive from the My Computer list and optionally files or folders from the right pane and press the READ! button.

Download CDReader 3.0


3. Emsa DiskCheck

emsa diskcheck running a file scan

Although this program is completely free to use, it does have a rather odd registration system because you have to click the red “Activate product here” link on the Emsa web page to be given a key to activate DiskCheck. It’s not a major issue, just an odd setup. DiskCheck can check the integrity of the data on floppies, hard drives and also CD/DVD-ROM discs, they’re chosen from the disk type and drive letter drop down menus in the top left. The “flush cache on start” option is useful to keep checked as it stops any files cached by the system being mistakenly scanned instead of the files on the disc. There’s plenty of scan stats and any resulting file errors will show in the main window.

Download Emsa DiskCheck


4. Dvdisaster

dvdisaster surface scan result

Dvdisaster is actually an application to provide built in recoverable data on your optical media to help repair your files in the event of read errors. It does this using error correction codes similar in some ways to a recovery record built into RAR archives etc. Another function of the program is the option to scan a CD or DVD for sector errors which will test the readability of the disc. Simply run the program, make sure the drive is selected from the drop down menu and then press Scan. Obviously you are looking for all green sectors in the medium state graphic and a smooth speed line without any severe drops to the bottom of the graph. One drawback is you can’t see the exact files that are affected, just the sectors of the disc.

Download Dvdisaster


5. Nero DiskSpeed

nero diskspeed surface error display

Most users will have heard of Nero’s burning application and DiskSpeed is a free utility that comes with the Nero suite and is available also as a standalone program. Sadly more recent versions have followed the bloated nature of the Nero Burning ROM software itself and the setup installer of DiskSpeed is now an eye watering 30MB! Thankfully an older portable version from Nero v9 still works fine and does the same job, it’s less than 4MB though.

DiskSpeed looks like the hard drive diagnostic tool HD Tune in many ways and has separate tabs to run a benchmark test of the media and drive, test burning reliability, get information about the media, test it’s quality (ROM drive permitting) and also a complete surface scan of the inserted disc. This last test will tell you which areas of the CD/DVD are good, damaged or bad with a color coded graph and the affected files listed in red at the bottom with a quality score. Note this test can take a while if several errors are found on the disc.

Download Nero DiskSpeed | Download older 4MB portable version

13 Comments - Write a Comment

  1. Marco 2 years ago
  2. Mark 7 years ago
  3. Deejam 7 years ago
  4. TCzzz 7 years ago
  5. Sp 7 years ago
  6. delta55 7 years ago
  7. webcadre 7 years ago
  8. Chris 7 years ago
  9. Firas 7 years ago
  10. roy raay 7 years ago
  11. shan 7 years ago
  12. gaurav 7 years ago
  13. vasek608 7 years ago

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Note: Your comment is subject to approval. Read our Terms of Use. If you are seeking additional information on this article, please ask in our forum or contact us directly.